Thursday, June 28, 2012

Family Wisdom

My grandfather is one of the most upstanding human beings I have ever met.  Since I was a little girl, I have always felt I could never in a million years soak up enough of his wisdom.  When he speaks, I listen. 

One of his favorite reminders to his children and grandchildren has stayed with me throughout the years.  “Before you open your mouth,” he would say, “ask yourself these three questions – is it true?, is it kind?, and will it help?  If the answer is not ‘yes’ to all three, keep it to yourself.”

The deeper I dive into the field of prospect research, the more I realize that this advice holds true in our work as well.  Before I send information to a gift officer, I like to ask myself my grandfather’s three questions.

Is it true? – If there is any question of a source’s validity, have I cross-checked against other resources?  Is information volunteered by peers or development officers able to be verified using public information?  If not, depending on the significance of the information, I may mention it with a disclaimer that it could not be verified.  Otherwise, I may remove the information altogether.

Is it kind? – There are varying schools of thought when it comes to this concept.  I do believe we need to provide the best, most comprehensive information possible to our gift officers.  However, if there is sensitive information to share such as bankruptcy, criminal filings, or domestic troubles, I seriously evaluate the most appropriate way to share this information.  Obviously, it should always be shared in a way that is confidential and fact-based.  Sometimes it may be most appropriate to say something “off record” about such topics.  Different people have different ideas about how this information should be handled; the point is, we should never villainize our constituents.

Will it help? – This one is my favorite.  Although the prospect research application is slightly different than what my grandfather originally had in mind, the concept remains the same:  will this add something to the conversation?  As researchers we come across a great deal of information.  However, whenever possible, it is our role to filter this information into what will help the gift officer hone in on philanthropic interests and capacity.  Sometimes we don’t know what will help until we are elbow-deep in a project – it’s hard to know when a board of directors for a small organization halfway across the country will wind up being the link between a prospect and one of our trustees.  If nothing else, it is our role to highlight these things that “help.”
What do you think?  Do these questions shed any new light on your work?  Do you have any other simple mantras that guide your daily efforts? 

Caroline Rossini, Treasurer, APRA MidSouth
treasurer@apramidsouth.org

Friday, June 22, 2012

The Popsicle Theory of Prospect Research

I love popsicles.

I would say I love popsicles because it’s summer, but I must confess I love them year-round. Orange Dream Bars, Fudgsicles, Dove Bars, Bomb Pops, Peace Pops -- you name it. And don’t even get me started on the Double Caramel Magnum Ice Cream Bar.

How, you may be asking, does this relate to prospect research? Searching for our ideal prospects is like searching for people who love popsicles. It wouldn’t be enough just to search for people who love frozen treats. Who has time to wade through lovers of ice cream, sorbet, ice cream sandwiches, frozen yogurt, and milkshakes, etc.? Likewise, we can’t just focus on people who love food on a stick. We’d have to deal with people who love candy apples, roasted marshmallows, corndogs (pogo dogs for our Canadian friends!), and chicken satay. Our ideal combination is people who love frozen treats and people who love food on a stick. Those are your popsicle lovers.
In prospect research, pursuing wealthy people who don’t care about my mission is a waste of time and money. Likewise, pursuing people who have all the enthusiasm in the world for my mission but not the capacity for a substantial gift is also not a good return on investment. The way to be strategic and to wisely use your limited resources of time, money, and energy is to not be distracted by one or the other. Use the resources at your disposal and your own expertise to focus on people with capacity and inclination. Those are your prospects.

This is a pretty basic concept, but I hope I’ve helped you think about gift capacity and inclination in a new way. At the very least, I’ve made you think about popsicles. 



Mitch Roberson, Communications Director, APRA MidSouth
communications@apramidsouth.org

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Advice for the One-Person Prospect Research Office

While some shops are blessed with the resources to have several people assisting with prospect research requests, often it is the case in smaller shops that all of that responsibility falls to one person.   What’s more, if you are like me, there are several other areas you are responsible for in addition to prospect research.

So, what’s a one-person prospect research office to do?   Keep your door closed and refuse to answer the phone?   Run screaming from your office?   Although some days these seem like the answer, I’m here to offer some advice from what I have learned as an organization’s sole prospect researcher.

Look for free/cheap help (i.e., interns)

While your organization may not be able to hire any full or part-time staff to assist in the prospect research needs of the office, there are other alternatives.   Over the years, I have hired several graduate students to help with prospect research and have found that it was a win-win situation.   There are always students who are looking for employment experience and possibly a little extra income.   And, as the sole researcher, you need help.   A perfect match!   This is also a wonderful way to introduce students to the world of fundraising and help them start building a resume.   Let’s face it – fundraising is often a career that many people fall into or are introduced to by someone else.   Being able to show someone the ins and outs of fundraising is a great way to train a future fundraiser or prospect researcher.

Teach fundraisers how to help themselves

In my role, I support an office of about 12 fundraisers.   Since there is only one of me and several of them, there are often more requests for research than one person can handle.   The good news, though, is that there are numerous free online research resources that can provide a great base for a prospect profile.   I have provided training to the fundraisers in our office on simple techniques they can use to determine the basic capacity of a prospect.   This is especially helpful in regards to new prospects or discovery calls. (As a side note, many of these free resources are covered in APRA MidSouth’s Prospect Research 101 seminar and listed in other posts on this blog.)

Prioritize requests

It’s important to prioritize your requests when you are working with limited staffing resources.   Although there will be some exceptions, try to reserve full research profiles for the top 10% or 20% of your donor database.   This will help you dedicate more of your time to those prospects with the most resources.   Other prospects can be researched by the fundraiser themselves or given to your intern.

Know when to say when

When determining the length and depth of a research profile, I find that it’s helpful to keep these questions in mind: 1) is specific information needed? 2) what will be the end use of the information?   For the first point, if the fundraiser is only looking for specific information (value of stock, sale of a business, etc.) then a full research profile may not be needed.   Learning to communicate with fundraisers on what exactly they are looking for will help you in the long run.   On the second point, thinking about what the information will be used for can help you determine the depth of your research.   For example, if someone requests research for several people for an event, you just need to hit the highlights and provide fundraisers with good talking points.   On the other hand, if it is for a one-on-one ask for a campaign, you’ll need a more in-depth profile.   Trying to keep these things in mind will help you from potentially spending too much of your (limited) time on a research request.

Anna G. Verner, Membership Director, APRA MidSouth
membership@apramidsouth.org

Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Dallas Research Resources

A few months ago, I moved from Dallas, Texas, to Nashville, Tennessee. I have learned many new resources from my colleagues and was eager to share a few sites with the team. Here are a few sites to keep in mind when researching prospects in Texas.
DFW Most Powerful: http://www.dfwmostpowerful.com/index.htm
  • The site includes lists of the most expensive homes, most powerful events, most powerful couples, etc.
My Sweet Charity: http://mysweetcharity.com/
  • This site features people, events, and noteworthy philanthropic causes in the North Texas area.
PaperCity: http://www.papercitymag.com/
  • It’s a great source to follow events in Houston and Dallas, Texas.
I hope you find these helpful!
Melissa Sridaromont, Secretary, APRA MidSouth
secretary@apramidsouth.org

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

After the Campaign Winds Down – What Next?

I have come to the end of a road in my job as a prospect researcher. A place I have never been. Western Kentucky University’s $200 million “A New Century of Spirit” Campaign will close at the end of our fiscal year on June 30, 2012.

I am one of many in our division of development and alumni relations who cannot believe we have finally reached this end. This milestone. This finish line. Without revealing details (we are sworn to secrecy on the final number), we can definitely call it a success.

This is the second capital campaign undertaken by WKU. Our first capital campaign closed on June 30, 2003, with $102 million in gifts and pledges. Our “A New Century of Spirit” campaign followed with a public launch in September 2007.

When I joined the staff in July 2005 we were in the midst of the second campaign’s silent phase. As prospect researchers, you know that even though the word may not be out to the public, hard work hums along behind the scenes – we still identify and rate prospects, prepare briefs and bios, and perform all other prospect research and management duties.

So, I began my journey on the prospect research road in the midst of this second campaign. I had to hit the ground running, learn on the fly, and just go with it. (I know many of you can relate to that sentiment every day!)

While I have learned a lot over the seven (!) years I have been at WKU, I feel like I am still just beginning to wade into the pool (or is it better to describe it as an ocean?) of prospect research. Yes, there is still so much to learn. Including what happens when reaching this place in the campaign road.

As this campaign winds down, I certainly have a smile on my face for the good work done and what we have accomplished. However, along with that sigh of satisfaction a wrinkle crosses my brow and a question invades my mind.

“What next?”

My boss and I have a list of changes we want to make to our systems and processes. I know we will continue in our prospect research and management duties as fundraising will definitely go on.

I know another campaign is in WKU’s future. But until it’s announced and we are in campaign mode once again, we have another kind of “silent phase” – one in which much work still needs to be accomplished. With all that to think about, questions continually pop to mind.

So, in an effort to get a grasp on this new place I have reached as a prospect researcher, what it means and what to do next, I throw some of these questions out to you colleagues who have been down this road:

  • What have you done at the end of a campaign?
  • What changes have you made?
  • What processes have you established or eliminated?
  • What preparations have you made to be ready for the next campaign?

While WKU has a two person shop, I would love to hear from anyone no matter the size of your operation. Although we may work for different sizes and types of institutions, prospect research and management is something we all do.

I am excited to learn from you. And if I learn something along the way, I’ll be sure and share it while we wait for the next WKU campaign to begin.

Theresa Clark, Board Advisor, Western Kentucky University
at.large@apramidsouth.org

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Ah, the Request to Update a Profile… Which of the “Three C’s” Do You Use?

As a researcher, part-time or full-time, it takes just a short while of working with a front line fundraising staff/development officer(s) to receive the following kind of request, typically by email. Please note the fictional conversation below. 

[Email to me] Hi Geoff. I am visiting with Wellathee Parsons in two weeks here in town.
It looks like the last research profile completed on her was over a year ago.
Can you update this profile? Be in touch. Warmly, Colleen Ewes, Sr. Development Officer
Hmm. This prospect doesn’t immediately ring a bell. It hasn’t been on mine or my development officer’s radar (that I know of). I look them up in my organization’s development database. Ahh, Ms. Parsons, the partner in the big downtown law firm. I see that Ms. Parsons has minimal involvement with my group. However, she is a long-time corporate real estate attorney. She is rated to have high capacity because of her impressive real estate and compensation amounts. I see that her husband has attended an event with my organization, but that was six years ago. I see that the couple has contributed only a handful of token gifts over the years, $1,500 total. I see the last research profile. It is over 18 months old, and is in the old format. It looks a little stale to me, but does still have all of the key info, at least at first blush.

<Moments of indecision. Ranges of emotion.>

My workload is packed at present. I have barely begun one assignment lately without another request coming through. Colleen already has two other profiles/projects requests out to me. I have barely started those.

What is the best response to Colleen?

Let’s look at three hypothetical responses I might email back. I will call them the “Three C’s” for three distinct choices…

1. Compliance.

Thanks, Colleen, for your request. I will add this profile to my work queue and have for you as soon as possible. I understand you need it before two weeks from now when you visit Ms. Parsons.

2. Contention.

Hi Colleen, I was just beginning the earlier project you gave me last week – on finding 25 best prospects for you in Atlanta for your trip next month – when this new request came through. I am not sure if you understand the time it takes to complete a profile, even an update. It is easily three to four hours to go through the many research areas; then, it must be proofed and finalized. This all takes a lot of time. I’m sorry if I sound upset. I am a bit overwhelmed. I will be happy to have my supervisor contact you if that would be helpful. I will try to get to this work as soon as possible.

3. Collaboration.

Hi Colleen. That’s great that you were able to get a lunch scheduled with Ms. Parsons! After reviewing her information in our database, I see we have tried to meet with her several times, but she has been unable to make an appointment fit her schedule. You finally got to her!

Instead of recreating a profile, I wonder if I could get for you key information you are thinking of for this prospect. Are there specific questions you have about Ms. Parsons, even judging from her past profile? Perhaps you have questions about her wealth capacity, social/community connections, or current public philanthropy? I bet I could confirm these areas looking up a few things in our our subscriber resources. I could do this quickly and email you my results. I’ll of course also save it into our database at her record. I am especially busy in my department at present. Thoughts? Please let me know if this plan sounds okay.

Of course, I can’t tell you which “C” to choose. The best one may not be available to you – for reasons beyond your control. If this is the case, oh well.

But the best practice is for the researcher-development officer relationship to be framed by the word partnership. How might this be defined? Here are two suggestions: A) What can you do to help a development officer be most successful – to truly advance relationship(s) they have with their prospect to the solicitation stage? Is the answer really a profile update? And B) For your sake, in terms of flexibility, what can a development officer do to be flexible to you so that you can provide the greatest net impact for them, and for your organization? In other words, let’s think bigger picture, and bigger reward!

Building a collaborative, mutually satisfying, and tension-free workflow with a front line/development officer is a continual challenge, even for the most seasoned prospect research professional. However, it is no less a vital objective to plan for, even every day. Obviously, this goal requires careful, humble communication. Today’s best research staffers are careful to quietly, professionally under-promise and over-deliver what they can do when presented with a new project. They look for ways to compress a research request to its purest business need for the overall organization, and they communicate it through a collaborative framework.

Geoffrey Little, President, APRA MidSouth
president@apramidsouth.org

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Building Relationships with Gift Officers

One of the challenges of prospect research can be stepping back from our quest for information in order to build relationships with the gift officers we serve. These relationships, however, have as much to do with a successful career in research as does knowing where to find the right information. Here are some ideas to help you expand and develop your relationships with gift officers.

  • Reach out. Playing offense can help you to stay a step ahead. Find out what your gift officer’s priorities are for the month, quarter, or year. Then think of ways you can help him achieve his goals.
  • Ask for clarification. Often a gift officer has something very particular in mind when she asks for research. When appropriate, ask questions to gain a better understanding of what information she wants most. These sorts of clues can help you find better information, narrow your focus, and show you are committed to providing what the gift officer needs. All of this in turn means you provide a better product, and everyone is happier!
  • Stay abreast of travel plans and prospect visits. Finding a way to stay tuned in to your gift officer’s plans will help you to be proactive. If he is travelling to another city, you could suggest a list of prospects he might want to call. If he has a meeting with Mr. Smith, you could do a quick search to see if there has been any news on Mr. Smith recently.
  • Share relevant news stories or articles. Finding news on prospects is extremely helpful to gift officers – knowing the good, the bad, and the ugly helps them to plan strategies for cultivation and solicitation. Even if a gift officer has already seen an article, she will be impressed that you picked up on the connection.
  • Choose your communication method wisely. Email seems to rule our world, especially for those of us who are constantly searching for information online. Picking up the phone can be useful when a complex question needs answering or when it is time for negotiating. Always seek out opportunities for occasional face-to-face contact, too. Finding a balance of these three communication methods will help to keep communication flowing.

These are a few ways to help build relationships with gift officers. What works for you? Leave a comment below.

Caroline Rossini, Treasurer, APRA MidSouth
treasurer@apramidsouth.org

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Rich Lists

The following link shows a compilation of various rich lists. It looks like it will be particularly useful for international research. The U.S. lists are at the bottom.

http://www.helenbrowngroup.com/services/the-rich-list/

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

NY Times Survey of Highest-Paid CEOs

Recently, The New York Times published its annual survey of the 100 highest-paid CEOs in America in an article entitled “In Executive Pay, a Rich Game of Thrones.” The article discusses the compensation packages of the top CEOs and illustrates overall executive compensation trends at the most successful U.S. companies.

(Here’s the NYT article: http://tinyurl.com/6q7j8db)

Equilar, the company who supplies the compensation data for NYT’s surveys each year, took it a step further and wrote a follow-up analysis of the NYT’s study. (Link to Equilar’s response: http://tinyurl.com/7lbldxh)

A few of their key findings:
  • CEOs from Consumer Goods companies make up the largest share of the list, while Utilities make up the smallest group.
  • Technology CEOs received the most equity, with 90 percent of compensation received in options or stock/units. On the other hand, Industrial companies paid out 53 percent of compensation in cash.
  • Among all CEOs on the list, 50 percent of all value was given through time- and performance-based stock awards.

Among many other points, the NYT’s article makes the bold statement that business is back to usual following the 2009 recession. CEOs are back to taking large base salaries and even more in terms of stock awards. Seven-figures is the new six-figures.

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Surviving the Swirl of Prospect Research

Swirl.

Sometimes my mind as a Prospect Researcher is in a constant state of swirl. How about you?
When I first joined WKU I came on working part-time in prospect research and part-time in stewardship. It was a good job combo so I could get my feet wet in the world of university fundraising.

Then the Prospect Researcher moved to a position as a Development Officer and I was given the opportunity to move into her spot full-time. I jumped at the chance. And inherited the swirl.
We were in the middle of the silent phase of our current campaign. It was time for a new wealth screening of the database. We were upgrading Advance (then known as BSR) from windows-based to the new Advance Web. We needed to find those major gift prospects. How do we manage and track the prospects – old and new? And…...well, you get the picture.

Yep, talk about a mind swirl. Exciting, interesting, but definitely whirling and swirling to get a hold of it all as I learned to do this thing called “Prospect Research.”

That’s when something great happened in the life of this Prospect Researcher. A group of Prospect Researchers in the middle Tennessee area decided that it was time to go small. APRA National is a great organization – great information, great networking, great opportunities – but a bit overwhelming for a 1 ½ person shop like mine to know where to go for help. And I was not just saying “help” meekly I was yelling it from the rooftops – HELP! (No panic involved –well maybe a little…)

This start-up group of Prospect Researchers based mainly out of Vanderbilt University, realized that the Midsouth (i.e. Alabama, Mississippi, Tennessee and Kentucky) needed a networking group to connect Prospect Researchers of all sizes and organizations on a more regional level. A group closer together would make it easier to reach each other, to share information, ideas, and opportunities. And much more.

Can you hear me say “Hallelujah?” I almost ran from Bowling Green to Nashville to join (not really, but it sounds good, right?) In the few years since its formation, I have spent many hours with the APRA MidSouth group. They have shared time, ideas, information, themselves. Honestly, for me and our small shop, it has been a life (and mind swirl) saver.

Looking on the other side of WKU’s A New Century of Spirit Campaign (we finish as of June 30, 2012) I am in the mode of assessing how we made it through, what to change and what to do as we prepare for the next campaign (and that includes the help of a new Director of Prospect Research who just joined us).

One thing I know for sure, that no matter how much mind swirling all this review and reloading brings, my friends at APRA MidSouth have helped prepare me for what comes next. Thanks, guys. Thanks for helping me get through the swirls. And I’m here to help you get through yours.

Theresa Clark, Board Advisor, Western Kentucky University
at.large@apramidsouth.org